Secret Santa, ring the bells!
The Reverse Thieves elves brought us a task this year. That is: watch anime. For this we were instructed to pick three series/movies to force a fellow blogger to watch.
From my Santa I received Kure-nai, Sora wo Miageru Shoujo no Hitomi ni Utsuru Sekai (AKA Munto), and Mushi-Uta. We were supposed to watch two out of the three and review write about them. I watched all three, but I have only chosen two of them to review write about.
This was a fun experience, but I think my Santa was trying to troll me.
Anyway, on to the posts.
Kure-nai
“It’s okay, Shinkurou. This is farewell.”
The tears stream down her face, and she walks off into episode ten, titled “Accustomed Fear”.
The trained dog aspect of the Kuhouin family was probably the most upsetting part of this show to me. Not even that the members of the family are quashed and forced into doing what tradition and family law says, but that they actually think it’s the proper course of action.
That they actually think it’s fine –right, even– to force young girls to live in solitude in the Inner Sactuary of their house. Or that said young girls think that it is their place to live that way, because that is what tradition has taught them. That is what family brainwashing has taught them.
Murasaki knows what is waiting for her at her home. She knows, and she fears it, but in order to fulfill her family duty and protect Shinkurou, she is willing to give up her freedom and embrace that fear anyway.
She is seven-years-old. Her life is that of slavery to the family. This is sad.
It doesn’t make it any less sad that this sort of thing is something that really happened to children in the past. Or that it happens now. Or that it could happen in the future.
It’s sad.
Murasaki is the princess trapped in the castle, and it’s Shinkurou’s duty to save her. To repay the sacrifice she made to keep him safe when the Kuhouins came calling to take him away. And this becomes like a knight’s tale.
The knight sets out on his quest. He has a mission, and he has divine support (or perhaps, Benika and Yayoi’s support). He moves forward, and he is met with challenges. Traffic, cold, being discovered the instant he sets foot on Kuhouin property.
The knight runs into a guard before the tower, a defenseless woman protecting the entrance to the Inner Sanctuary. She tries to stop him from harming himself; she ends up sacrificing herself for the sake of the princess and the knight. Blood is spilled on the quest.
And then, the knight reaches the princess in the tower, and she says she doesn’t want to go with him. That she wants to remain where she is.
The knight has failed in his mission.
He starts the journey, he gains support, he makes sacrifices, he overcomes challenges: and the girl refuses to go. The story of the girl is transformed from one of obedient following to that of defiance. Defiance that traps her further; obligated defiance. But defiance nonetheless.
The knight knows her will better than she does. The knight returns to save her once more. But that moment of defiance is still powerful. It’s better than her meekly sitting there and being pulled between one family and the other.
“I’m still weak,” Shinkurou says.
“You’re like me then. I must change too,” Murasaki replies.
The princess knows that she must learn to develop this defiance further. She learns by the end of the show how to break away from obligation and how to stick up for her opinions. She goes from a sheltered girl trying to be brave in the face of fear to a girl who looks at fear and defeats it.
“I have seen many Kuhouins smile. But they are crooked smiles. I will not accept them.”
She refuses to allow her family’s traditions, even those of deception or lies to self, stand. She knocks them away, and the crosses the threshold out of the Inner Sanctuary as a more enlightened person. As a much stronger person already.
To me, it is this strength that Murasaki gains throughout the course of the show that is the most powerful thing. It is the ability of this seven-year-old to look at her life, to look at her happiness, and make a choice on her own.
Years and tradition of oppression to a decision powered by her and her alone.
Because the show is definitely about the princess, not the knight.
It’s a radical transition.
–
Sora wo Miageru Shoujo no Hitomi ni Utsuru Sekai (AKA Munto)
>my crooked smile when this show is so horrible I want to laugh, but it hurts so bad I can’t.
Really, Santa? Really?
–





12 comments
December 24, 2010 at 2:40 pm
fangzhao
Munto is one of those rare shows that is downright terrible, but still not bad enough to be good. Look on the bright side, though – at least you didn’t get Apocalypse Zero…
<< has not watched Kure-nai
December 24, 2010 at 3:24 pm
mefloraine
Nope, it’s just bad. Just. bad.
I think of I got Apocalypse Zero I would have clawed my eyes out at some point and never would have made this post.
Kure-nai was good though~
December 25, 2010 at 12:34 pm
Secret Santa 2010 Project Reveal « Reverse Thieves
[...] reviewed Kure-nai and Sora wo Miageru Shoujo no Hitomi ni Utsuru Sekai recommended by [...]
December 25, 2010 at 2:08 pm
Shinmaru
I watched Munto week-by-week when it first aired.
Yeah.
/wrists
December 25, 2010 at 2:51 pm
mefloraine
Why didn’t you stop before it was too late?
December 25, 2010 at 2:52 pm
Shinmaru
I was blinded by KyoAni fanboyism. Also, I’m dumb.
December 25, 2010 at 3:04 pm
mefloraine
Pffft. And suddenly, clarity.
December 26, 2010 at 1:36 am
Taka
I kept hoping something would happen.
It sucks that it’s yknow…gorgeous…like all KyoAni but I fell asleep in the last episode, twice.
December 26, 2010 at 10:41 am
Omisyth
>Munto
No. Just… no.
December 26, 2010 at 11:26 am
mefloraine
So horrible.
December 26, 2010 at 4:31 pm
reversethieves
Your review of Kure-nai was hardly traditional but it cuts right to the heart of the matter of what the series is about. It also gives me a good amount of insight into what you liked most about the series. As someone who always writes editorial pieces during the manga movable feast I am always appreciate of someone who does something a bit different for these projects.
If I remember correctly Narutaki mildly enjoyed the original Munto but could not watch any of the new series.
Well I am glad you got some enjoyment of of your choices despite the fact that the person giving you pics seemed a bit unsure of what you like. I hope we will see you again next year!
- Hisui
December 26, 2010 at 5:56 pm
mefloraine
Haha, well, it’s not much of a review, but it’s relevant, and it does explain the heart of the story. So I didn’t craft it back into a review style.
My Santa didn’t think I’d watch Munto…XD
But you’ll see me again, I think! It was fun! ;3